
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa
Best for soaking and spa-focused stays — on-site geothermal mineral pools and a dedicated MoonAcre Spa make it a clear pick for guests who want hot-springs-style relaxation.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa is a midcentury-inspired, family-friendly Napa Valley hotel centered on geothermal mineral pools and MoonAcre Spa — read this if you want easy access to downtown Calistoga, soak-based spa treatments, and a wood-fired restaurant. Silverado Resort is a larger, well-known Napa-area resort with broad resort amenities (golf, tennis, multiple dining outlets and a full spa) — read this if you want a traditional full-service resort with many on-site activities.
Updated

Best for soaking and spa-focused stays — on-site geothermal mineral pools and a dedicated MoonAcre Spa make it a clear pick for guests who want hot-springs-style relaxation.

Best for broad resort amenities and organized activities — a long list of on-site facilities (golf course, tennis courts, multiple F&B outlets and event spaces) suits travelers who want a one-stop resort.
When Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa wins: choose Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa if your priority is geothermal pools, intimate spa treatments (MoonAcre Spa & Baths), a walkable downtown Calistoga location, and a smaller, more focused hotel experience with a single signature restaurant (Fleetwood).
When Silverado Resort wins: choose Silverado Resort if you want a larger, classic Napa resort with a wider range of on-site activities and facilities (golf, tennis, several dining/drink options, fitness/spa services and a bigger roster of room types) and prefer resort-scale programming.
Bottom line: pick Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa for a hot-springs, spa-and-soak–driven Calistoga stay close to town; pick Silverado Resort for a more traditional, full-service Napa resort with broader on-site sports and event facilities.
| Category | Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa | Silverado Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Midcentury-inspired boutique focusing on geothermal pools, spa and downtown access | Large, classic Napa-area resort with broad resort programming and facilities |
| Location | 1880 Lincoln Ave — walkable to downtown Calistoga, trails and hot-springs attractions | 1600 Atlas Peak Rd, Vichy Springs (Napa area) — set on a larger resort property outside a small town center |
| Size | Reported ~102 rooms, plus a 50-room expansion announced | Not published |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-friendly with a designated adults-only pool/quiet hours | All ages — not adults-only |
| Pools | Multiple outdoor geothermal mineral pools (2–4 reported), adults-only soaking options and quiet-soak hours | Outdoor pool(s) and spa facilities listed; hot-tub, sauna and steamroom among amenities |
| Restaurants & bars | Fleetwood — single signature wood-fired Italian/Mediterranean restaurant and bar on-site | Multiple F&B outlets and bars listed in supplier amenities (restaurants, poolside bar, coffee shop) |
| Spa & wellness | MoonAcre Spa & Baths — full-service spa with massages, mineral mud, steam room and soaking tubs | On-site spa with massage, sauna, steamroom and treatment offerings (The Spa at Silverado listed among highlights) |
| Sports & activities | Complimentary cruiser bikes, nearby hiking/biking trails, yoga and concierge-arranged local activities | On-site golf course, tennis courts, fitness/fitness center, bicycles and organized tours listed |
| Events & meeting space | Multiple outdoor and indoor event spaces (Outdoor Event Pad, Fleetwood Meeting Room, Moon Room) and wedding capacity up to ~100 | Meeting/banquet facilities available on-site (supplier listing includes meeting/banquet), larger resort meeting capabilities implied |
| Rating & class | 4-star boutique property (brand-affiliation changed in 2025); widely rated for pools and spa | 4-star resort; guest rating 8.5 (supplier listing) |
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa sits at 1880 Lincoln Ave at the northern end of Napa Valley and is within easy walking distance of downtown Calistoga and nearby trails.
Best if you want immediate access to Calistoga’s downtown, trails and hot-springs attractions.
Silverado Resort is located at 1600 Atlas Peak Rd in the Vichy Springs/Napa area on a larger resort property outside a small town center.
Best if you plan to drive around Napa Valley and want a resort base with broad on-site facilities.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa offers a compact range of room and suite types with midcentury touches and in-room conveniences.
Choose Calistoga for a smaller set of distinctive rooms and multiple suite layouts close to spa and pools.
Silverado Resort provides a long list of room types across cottages, mansion rooms and residence suites, suited to different party sizes.
Choose Silverado if you need a broader selection of room configurations across a larger resort property.
Fleetwood is Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa’s single signature restaurant and bar, focusing on wood-fired Italian- and Mediterranean-style dishes.
Fleetwood provides a focused on-site dining option centered on wood-fired seasonal dishes and a full bar.
Silverado Resort lists multiple food-and-beverage outlets and bars among its amenities, supporting a resort-style dining offering.
Pick Silverado if you want more on-site dining options and casual poolside choices without leaving the resort.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa centers its appeal on geothermal mineral-water pools, clawfoot soaking tubs and hot-springs–style experiences.
If soaking in mineral pools and a hot-springs spa experience is your priority, Calistoga is the clearer choice.
Silverado Resort lists outdoor swimming facilities and spa/sauna/steamroom among its amenities as part of a broad resort leisure program.
Silverado gives you typical resort-style pool and spa facilities as part of a wider activity set rather than a geothermal-focused experience.
MoonAcre Spa & Baths is Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa’s full-service spa that integrates mineral soaks, mud treatments and massages.
Calistoga focuses on spa-led wellness with geothermal treatments and scheduled classes.
Silverado Resort provides spa services plus a variety of recreational and fitness features on the property.
Silverado suits guests who want a mix of spa services and on-site sports/activities under one resort umbrella.

Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa — multiple mineral pools, clawfoot soaking tubs and MoonAcre Spa treatments focused on mineral mud and soaking.

Silverado Resort — supplier listing includes an on-site golf course, tennis courts and many traditional resort amenities.

Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa — within easy walking distance of downtown Calistoga shops, tasting rooms and hot-springs attractions.

Silverado Resort — multiple restaurants, bars and poolside F&B options listed in the supplier amenities.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa: MoonAcre Spa & Baths centers on mineral-soak treatments and mud therapies and ties directly into the hotel's geothermal pools.
Silverado Resort: the supplier listing includes an on-site golf course, tennis courts and a wider assortment of resort amenities.
Standalone day passes are not sold; spa-treatment guests receive a Day Spa Pass that includes pool access before or after their service.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages. Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa maintains an adults-only pool/quiet-soak hours within an otherwise family-friendly property; Silverado Resort is listed as all-ages.
Pick Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa for a soak- and spa-first experience close to Calistoga town; pick Silverado Resort for a traditional, full-service resort with more on-site sports, dining and activities.
Explore how Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·