
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa
Best for geothermal mineral soaks and a property with multiple pools plus a full-service on-site spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa is a family-friendly, midcentury-inspired 4-star Calistoga hotel with geothermal mineral pools, Fleetwood wood-fired dining, and MoonAcre Spa — good for travelers who want hot-springs access, multiple pools, and on-site spa experiences. Napa Valley Lodge is a 4-star Yountville lodge-style hotel with resort amenities, a pool and hot tub, and easy access to Yountville restaurants and tasting rooms — a solid pick for travelers who want a central Yountville base near the French Laundry area.
Updated

Best for geothermal mineral soaks and a property with multiple pools plus a full-service on-site spa.

Best for travelers who want a central Yountville location with complimentary continental breakfast and a classic lodge feel.
When Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa wins: choose Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa if your priority is geothermal mineral pools, a fuller spa program (MoonAcre Spa & Baths), outdoor soaking options including an adults-only pool, and casual on-site wood-fired dining.
When Napa Valley Lodge wins: pick Napa Valley Lodge if you want to stay in central Yountville with easy walking access to its parks, tasting rooms and restaurants, a well-rated lodge-style property, free continental breakfast, and straightforward resort amenities (outdoor pool, hot tub, fitness/meeting facilities).
Bottom line: both are 4-star Napa Valley options serving different needs — Calistoga Motor Lodge leans into hot-springs, multiple pools and spa programming; Napa Valley Lodge is a quieter Yountville base with a strong guest rating and convenient location for exploring Yountville.
| Category | Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa | Napa Valley Lodge |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Midcentury-inspired motor lodge with active spa culture and family- and couple-friendly public spaces. | Lodge-style Yountville hotel with resort amenities and a quieter, small-town setting. |
| Location | 1880 Lincoln Avenue, Calistoga — at the northern end of Napa Valley, walkable to downtown Calistoga and nearby trails. | 2230 Madison Street, Yountville — central Yountville, a short walk to Yountville Park and nearby restaurants. |
| Size (rooms) | Reportedly about 102 rooms plus a recent 50-room expansion (varied sources). | 55 guestrooms (supplier listing). |
| Ages / check-in min | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 18; adults-only (21+) pool and evening quiet-soak hours. | All ages welcome; supplier listing notes children 12 and under stay free using existing bedding; check-in minimum age 21 per supplier policies. |
| Pools & water | Multiple outdoor geothermal mineral pools (2–4 reported) including an adults-only Jet Pool and Jacuzzi; daytime family access and adults-only quiet hours. | One outdoor pool and one hot tub listed; wheelchair-accessible pool. |
| Restaurants & bars | Fleetwood — on-site seasonal wood-fired Italian/Mediterranean restaurant and full bar (breakfast/brunch on weekends, dinner nightly, happy hour/locals night events). | No on-site signature restaurant name listed in the supplier data; hotel offers continental breakfast included; on-site food/beverage amenities implied by resort listing. |
| Spa / wellness | MoonAcre Spa & Baths — full-service spa with massages, mineral mud treatments, steam room, clawfoot soaking tubs and spa garden; reservations required for treatments. | Spa treatment room(s) and spa services listed on supplier listing; reservations required for treatments (some features and capacity noted). |
| Known for | Geothermal mineral pools, spa-led soaking experiences, complimentary cruiser bikes and proximity to Calistoga hot-springs attractions. | Central Yountville location, complimentary continental breakfast, vineyard/garden grounds and accessible meeting/banquet space. |
| Free breakfast | Not published as complimentary — breakfast is available for purchase (weekend cooked-to-order available for a fee). | Free continental breakfast is included daily (supplier listing). |
| Parking | Free self-parking on site, including RV/bus/truck parking. | |
Calistoga Motor Lodge sits at 1880 Lincoln Avenue at the northern end of Napa Valley, close to downtown Calistoga and nearby hiking trails.
Best if you want proximity to Calistoga’s hot-spring sites, trails and a more active outdoor setting.
Napa Valley Lodge is located at 2230 Madison Street in central Yountville, within easy walking distance of Yountville Park and top restaurants and tasting rooms.
Best if you want a central Yountville location with short walks to dining and tasting rooms.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa offers a mix of classic rooms and multiple suites, with in-room coffeemakers and rainfall showers.
Choose this property for larger suite options and family-friendly layouts when you want extra space.
Napa Valley Lodge lists 55 guestrooms across a range of courtyard, garden and vineyard-view rooms and suites.
Good if you prefer a smaller lodge property with courtyard and garden-room choices and private patios or balconies.
Fleetwood is Calistoga Motor Lodge’s on-site wood-fired restaurant and bar with a seasonal menu.
If on-site wood-fired dining and an active bar program matter, Fleetwood is a strong on-property choice.
Napa Valley Lodge’s supplier listing highlights complimentary continental breakfast and general F&B amenities but does not name an on-site signature restaurant in the provided listing.
Pick Napa Valley Lodge if a hotel with included continental breakfast and easy access to Yountville dining is important.
Calistoga Motor Lodge’s signature amenity is its geothermal mineral pools and soaking program tied to MoonAcre Spa.
Best for travelers prioritizing hot-springs soaking and varied pool experiences.
Napa Valley Lodge offers an outdoor pool and a hot tub as part of its resort amenities.
Better if you want a standard hotel pool and hot tub in a central Yountville setting rather than geothermal spa pools.
Calistoga Motor Lodge centers much of its wellness around MoonAcre Spa & Baths and pool programming.
Choose Calistoga for a stronger on-site wellness program and evening soak options.
Napa Valley Lodge lists spa services on site and standard resort wellness amenities in its supplier listing.
Best if you plan to use a hotel spa service and spend most evenings dining out in Yountville.

Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa — multiple geothermal pools, adults-only Jet Pool and strong spa programming.

Napa Valley Lodge — walkable to Yountville Park, tasting rooms and restaurants; a compact, central location.

Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa — family-friendly pools, kid-friendly dining options and extra-room suites available.

Napa Valley Lodge — complimentary continental breakfast is listed as included for guests.
Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa has the more extensive on-site spa (MoonAcre Spa & Baths) with mineral mud treatments and multiple spa facilities; Napa Valley Lodge lists spa services but with fewer published details.
Napa Valley Lodge lists a complimentary continental breakfast. Calistoga Motor Lodge does not publish complimentary breakfast as included; cooked-to-order weekend breakfast is available for a fee.
Yes — children are welcome in the main pools during daytime hours under adult supervision; the Jet Pool and some soak hours are reserved for adults 21 and over.
Napa Valley Lodge is better for walking to Yountville restaurants and tasting rooms; Calistoga Motor Lodge is walkable to downtown Calistoga but restaurants and tasting rooms are in a different, small-town cluster.
Explore how Calistoga Motor Lodge and Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·